CSCI 174: Fall 2024

AI, Ethics, & Society

CSCI 174: Fall 2024

Topics

Post-Helene Updates

Please note that this schedule is subject to change. It is your responsibility to keep up with the schedule by attending class and keeping up with the course announcements. See the syllabus for more information on the course format.

Unit 1. Introduction

Welcome to the course! In this unit, we will discuss why it is important to study how technology and society influence one another, and the increasing role that computation and artifical intelligence (AI) play in this complex landscape. To kick off the semester, we will watch some Black Mirror episodes (SciFi), discuss the many themes that these films raise, and connect them to numerous contemporary debates.

1.1 Intro to the Course: Tue, 08/20

Welcome to the course! This lecture discusses the course format, logistics, and general plan for the semester.

Tue, 8/20 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 1: Intro to the Course
Homework: Journal 1: Introductory Reflection
Readings (due before class):

1.2 An Introduction to AI and Society: Thu, 08/22

This lecture gives a very brief history and overview of AI. We will then analyze the two Black Mirror episodes and identify some of the themes and issues that each episode raises regarding AI and society.

Thu, 8/22 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 2: Intro to AI, Intro to Tech Ethics
Activity 1: Lecture Activity: Nosedive + Joan Is Awful
Homework: Forum 1: Black Mirror
  • Post due before class on Thu, 8/22.
  • Two peer responses due at midnight on Sun, 8/25.
Readings (due before class):

Unit 2. Doing the Right Thing

In this unit, we will learn about the psychological and philosophical roots of moral decisionmaking. On the social psychology side, scientists argue that human beings are "hard wired" with certain moral tendencies in certain social settings. These tendencies do not determine our moral decision-making, but they certainly shape it. Understanding some of these biological dispositions can help us better understand ourselves and why people act the way they do.

On the philosophy side, we will also learn about some of the moral frameworks that can help us analyze how people "ought" to behave in situations; and some of the ways that these frameworks can help people analyze what the "right thing to do" is. The goal of this unit is for you to practice analyzing controversies and situations in terms of the core values in play, using some key philosophical approaches (e.g. welfare, freedom, and virtue).

2.1 Biological & Psychological Foundations of Morality: Tue, 08/27

In this lecture, we will briefly consider the biology and psychology of moral decision-making. This includes examining the ways that humans tend to respond to certain situations, and how these tendencies can be diminished and amplified through our technologies.

Tue, 8/27 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 3: Biological & Psychological Foundations of Morality
Homework: Journal 2: The Science of Morality
Readings (due before class):

2.2 Intro to Moral Philosophy: Thu, 08/29

Over the next 2 lectures, we will be reading about moral philosophy, drawing from the Michael Sandel book, Justice: What's the right thing to do? There are many different ways to analyze moral dilemmas. By applying some of these ethical frameworks to real-world dilemmas, you will better understand the strengths and weaknesses of different approaches.

Thu, 8/29 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 4: Moral Philosophy: Part 1
Activity 2: Lecture Activity: Utilitarianism, Deontological Ethics, Libertarianism
Homework: Forum 2: Moral Philosophy
  • Post due before class on Thu, 8/29.
  • Two peer responses due at midnight on Sun, 9/1.
Readings (due before class):
  • : Sandel, Michael J. (2009). Chapter 1. Doing the Right Thing. Justice: What's the right thing to do?
  • : Chapter 2. Utilitarianism (Consequentialism)
  • : Chapter 3. Libertarianism
  • : Chapter 5. Kant (Deontological Ethics)
  • Pick One:
    • : Chapter 2. Utilitarianism (Consequentialism)
    • : Chapter 3. Libertarianism
    • : Chapter 5. Kant (Deontological Ethics)
Tue, 9/3 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 5: Moral Philosophy: Part 2
Activity 3: Lecture Activity: Rawles & Aristotle
Readings (due before class):
  • : Everyone should read Chapter 9. What do we owe one another? (Sandel, 2009).
  • : Chapter 6. Rawls
  • : Chapter 8. Aristotle (Virtue Ethics)
  • Pick One:
    • : Chapter 6. Rawls
    • : Chapter 8. Aristotle (Virtue Ethics)

Unit 3. Theories of Technology & Society

Over the next three weeks, we will be examining select topics in Science & Technology Studies (STS): an interdisciplinary field that studies the relationship between scientific knowledge, technological systems, and society. Some questions we will explore:

  • Is it possible for a technology to have politics and intent?
  • Do certain technological developments fundamentally alter how people think and live?
  • What does it mean for a technology or a dataset to be biased?
  • Who do our technologies over-serve / under-serve?
  • Why do we have the tendency to privilege technological solutions over other problem-solving approaches?
  • How has scientific authority been used to diminsh other forms of knowledge and experience? How has it advanced particular agendas?

3.1 The Politics of Technology: Thu, 09/05

Thu, 9/5 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 6: Do Artifacts Have Politics?
Homework: Forum 3: The Politics of Technology
  • Post due before class on Thu, 9/5.
  • Two peer responses due at midnight on Sun, 9/8.
Readings (due before class):

3.2 The Social Implications of Categorization & Classification: Tue, 09/10

Tue, 9/10 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 7: Race & the New Jim Code
Readings (due before class):
  • : Benjamin, Ruha (2019). Chapter 1. Engineered Inequity. Race After Technology.
  • optional: Atlas of AI – Chapter 4. Classification.
  • optional: Bowker & Star (1998). Sorting things out: Classification and its consequences. Introduction. MIT Press.
Thu, 9/12 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture : Paper Presentations
Readings (due before class):
  • : We will continue our discussion of race and the “New Jim Code” and present our paper topics during class.
Tue, 9/17 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 8: Categorization & Classification Systems
Activity 4: Lecture Activity: Massey & Thorne
Readings (due before class):

3.3 Critical Data Studies, Data and the Media: Thu, 09/19

Thu, 9/19 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 9: Critical Data Studies
Readings (due before class):
  • : Crawford, Kate (2021). Chapter 3. Data. Atlas of AI.
  • skim: D'Ignazio, Catherine & Klein, Lauren (2020). Introduction. Why Data Science Needs Feminism. Data Feminism. Read the introduction, but please also skim the chapter titles to get a sense of the book.
Tue, 9/24 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 10: Media Representation
Activity 5: Lecture Activity: Fake News Discussion
Homework: Journal 3: Identity, Categories, and the Media
Readings (due before class):

3.4 Technological Benevolence: Tue, 10/29

Tue, 10/29 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 11: Technological Solutionism
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 6: Lecture Discussion Questions: Solutionism
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 6 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Homework: Forum 4: Technological Solutionism
  • Post due before class on Tue, 10/29.
  • Two peer responses due at midnight on Thu, 10/31.
Readings (due before class):

3.5 Theories of Technology & Society: Recap: Thu, 10/31

Thu, 10/31 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 12: Midterm Reflection
Video : Lecture recording (Part 1)
Video : Lecture recording (Part 2)
Activity : Google Doc (In-Class)
Activity 7: Lecture Discussion Questions: Coded Bias
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 7 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Readings (due before class):

Unit 4. What is Intelligence?

Much has been said in the recent media about what it means for machines to be able to think, the extent to which machines can replace people, and whether it is even possible for Artifical General Intelligence (AGI) to be attained. In order to critically examine these questions, it is necessary to define what is meant by "intelligence" and to understand the different processes through which humans and machines learn.

Regarding human cognition, we will learn a little about how the human brain encode, store, retrieve, and act on information from the environment; and how social and cultural processes influence learning and development. We will also study how machines learn, including some of the statistical methods and algorithms that undergird different families of AIs (e.g., static and dynamic algorithms, reinforcement / supervised / unsupervised learning). Finally, we will discuss similarities and differences between human and machine learning.

4.1 Human Intelligence: Tue, 11/05

Tue, 11/5 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 13: How humans learn: Neuroscience & the Brain (Election Day)
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 8: Lecture Discussion Questions: The Brain
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 8 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Homework: Journal 4: AI & the Election
Readings (due before class):
Thu, 11/7 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 14: How humans learn: Developmental, social, & political processes
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 9: Lecture Discussion Questions: How People Learn
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 9 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Readings (due before class):

4.2 Machine Intelligence: Tue, 11/12

Tue, 11/12 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 15: Machine Intelligence Part 1: Intro to Computer Architecture
Video : Lecture recording (Part 1)
Video : Lecture recording (Part 2)
Activity 10: Lecture Discussion Questions: Computer Architecture
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 10 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Homework: Hw 2: Computer Architecture Lab
Readings (due before class):
Thu, 11/14 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 16: Machine Intelligence Part 2: Intro to Machine Learning
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 11: Lecture Discussion Questions: Deep Learning
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 11 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Homework: Hw 3: Machine Learning Lab (Extra Credit)
Readings (due before class):
Tue, 11/19 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 17: Machine Intelligence Part 3: Neuromorphic Computing
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 12: Lecture Discussion Questions: Neuromorphic Computing
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 12 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Readings (due before class):

Unit 5. Societal & Environmental Implications

A critical examination of the impact that computer-mediated systems have had in various domains (e.g., the environment, health, politics, news media, education, labor, policing, etc.).

5.1 Business Models: Thu, 11/21

Thu, 11/21 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 18: Business Models, Surveillance Capitalism, the Hype Cycle, and "Enshitification"
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 13: Lecture Discussion Questions: Business Models
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 13 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Readings (due before class):

5.2 The Environment: Tue, 11/26

Tue, 11/26 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 19: Energy, Water, Materials, and the Planet
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 14: Lecture Discussion Questions: The Environment
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 14 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Readings (due before class):
  • : Crawford, K. (2021). Chapter 1. Earth. In The Atlas of AI. Yale University Press.
    Available via JSTOR through the UNCA library.

5.3 The Future of Work: Tue, 12/03

Tue, 12/3 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 20: The Future of Work
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 15: Lecture Discussion Questions: The Future of Work
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 15 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Readings (due before class):

5.4 Critical Hope & Possibility: Thu, 12/05

Thu, 12/5 In-Class Activities (during class): Lecture 21: Critical Hope & Possibility
Video : Lecture recording
Activity 16: Lecture Discussion Questions: Design Justice
  • In lieu of attending class, you can complete and submit Activity 16 to the Moodle as your participation grade.
Readings (due before class):